Android & iOS App & Software Gadgets Review Tech

Ecobee Smart Doorbell Camera review: bigger view, fewer notifications


This morning, my doorbell rang, and I answered it from my thermostat. A picture of the FedEx driver appeared on the four-inch touchscreen, and I tapped the microphone icon and informed him I’d be proper there. Yeah, it was actually cool. 

The doorbell is the brand new launching as we speak on , Amazon, Greatest Purchase, and Lowes, and the thermostat is the superb Ecobee Sensible Thermostat Premium ($249.99). Streaming video doorbell feeds to sensible shows is nothing new, however this was a video feed to a thermostat. It’s sensible house symbiosis of one of the best sort. My solely criticism is that it took us this lengthy to get right here. 

The sensible thermostat was the darling of the house automation renaissance circa 2010 when Nest first burst onto the scene with its modern, twirly Nest Studying Thermostat. Whereas Nest obtained all of the press, Ecobee really got here first, and the place Nest below Google has lagged behind, Ecobee has been quietly innovating its flagship thermostat, together with turning it right into a hub for its sensible house ambitions. 

Right now, with the doorbell integration, the Ecobee Sensible Thermostat Premium is basically a sensible hub / show. Along with controlling your HVAC, it’s a sensible speaker with each Alexa and Siri built-in and acts as an indoor air high quality monitor, a smoke and CO alarm listener, a temperature and humidity sensor, plus it’s a radar-powered movement sensor. The corporate has additionally simply added the aptitude to be a keypad and siren for . 

How we price and assessment merchandise

I’ve spent the final two weeks testing Ecobee’s new Sensible Doorbell Digital camera alongside the sensible thermostat and sensible safety system. The digital camera does the fundamentals nicely — good video high quality, an outstanding discipline of view, quick alerts for individuals and packages, and glorious radar-powered movement detection. It really works with Apple House and Amazon Alexa (Google House help is slated for 2024).

Along with the distinctive skill to make use of a thermostat as a video intercom and to perform as a sensible safety hub, the Sensible Doorbell Digital camera also can zoom and observe a customer’s face earlier than they get to the door and ship tailor-made alerts that notify you solely of individuals and packages.

The large draw back is there isn’t any free or regionally saved recorded video; it’s all cloud-based. You’ll pay $5 a month ($50 a 12 months) for 30 days of motion-activated video clips. There’s additionally no 24/7 recording or facial recognition, that are options discovered on comparable doorbells on this worth level, together with Google Nest’s wired doorbell. 


The Sensible Thermostat Premium exhibiting a stay feed of the doorbell digital camera.

Moreover, I discovered a number of flaws in its new “sensor fusion” know-how, which makes use of radar movement detection, laptop imaginative and prescient, and machine studying to ship extra exact alerts. Chief amongst them is that if a bundle is in your doorstep and somebody approaches it, the doorbell doesn’t ship you an alert about that individual; its software program prioritizes the bundle. You possibly can see the issue right here.

Total, although, the innovation right here is spectacular. When paired with Ecobee’s door and window SmartSensors ($79.99 for two), the doorbell will be the hub for a easy safety system with video for below $240. If you happen to bump as much as the $10 a month ($90 a 12 months) Sensible Safety Full plan, you additionally get 24/7 skilled monitoring with video verification and recording for limitless cameras. That’s cheaper than all of the competitors. Ring’s pro-monitoring for its safety system with limitless digital camera recording is $20 month-to-month, and Arlo’s is $25. 

Mix this with an Ecobee thermostat and the corporate’s glorious indoor camera (that’s additionally a sensible speaker and siren for the alarm), and you’ve got a compelling system. A $399 bundle will get you the doorbell, Premium thermostat, and a 2-pack of safety sensors. 

I actually like that each system has two or extra capabilities, which means fewer devices to litter up your private home. The {hardware} makes use of high quality supplies and good industrial design, and the software program is simple to make use of with modern options — reminiscent of auto disarming when any family member arrives house.


Ecobee’s Sensible Indoor Digital camera shares design cues with the brand new doorbell digital camera.

Nonetheless, the safety system lacks key options discovered on Arlo, Ring, and others, together with no mobile or battery backup (the thermostat and the indoor digital camera are additionally each wired with no battery), and there’s no standalone outside digital camera and no possibility for a keyfob. However the total simplicity is strictly the kind of innovation the sensible house wants.

Moreover, in an age the place tech corporations seem to suppose we’re swapping out our doorbells and thermostats as typically as our telephones, Ecobee’s longevity method is a promoting level. Many of those enhancements are additionally coming to its whole vary of thermostats, ranging from the Ecobee 3. The stay view characteristic will work on the Premium, Enhanced, and Sensible Thermostat with Voice, the keypad characteristic on Ecobee 3 and newer, and all of its thermostats can act as a hub for the safety system.

The Ecobee Sensible Doorbell Digital camera is massive for a wired doorbell, with a black glass entrance and a white trim.

Specs and options

The Ecobee Sensible Doorbell Digital camera is a wired video doorbell with good high quality 1080p HD video, a 5MP sensor, and coloration and IR night time imaginative and prescient. It makes use of a mixture of radar movement detection and laptop imaginative and prescient to ship alerts when individuals or packages seem at your door. It has a superb 175-degree vertical discipline of view that confirmed me each these packages on my porch — even proper up towards the door — in addition to individuals’s faces. The one different doorbell I’ve examined that confirmed as a lot high to backside is the Wemo Video Doorbell (with a 178-degree vertical), however that has an overwrought fish-eye impact, whereas the Ecobee manages to look largely regular.

Design-wise, the Ecobee doorbell is nothing new. Black with a white casing and a distinguished button with an LED ring encircling it, it does have a high-end feel and look, with a machined glass entrance and an aluminum alloy again casing. I do want they’d allotted with the branding. For a wired buzzer that doesn’t want room for the large battery you discover in all battery-powered doorbells, it’s fairly massive. It additionally doesn’t have a back-up battery (frequent in wired doorbells). Ecobee says this helps it endure extra excessive temperatures. It’s IP65 rated and operates in temps of -13 to 113 levels Fahrenheit. It’s a light fall in South Carolina proper now, so I wasn’t capable of put this weatherproofing to the check.

The doorbell works with present mechanical and digital chimes and, by Amazon Alexa and Apple House integrations, also can use Echo audio system or HomePods to sound the alert when someone rings the doorbell.

Viewing a livestream and utilizing two-way speak by my iPhone and thru the thermostat was clean and audio was clear. I like the choice of activating the doorbell’s siren from the app, and you are able to do all this with out a subscription. Plus, you get free sensible alerts for individuals and the choice to set one exercise zone. 

You’ll have to pay if you need alerts for bundle detection, wealthy notifications, and limitless motion-activated recordings — every working a really lengthy two minutes. There’s no possibility for native storage or help for HomeKit Safe Video. Ecobee’s indoor digital camera did get HKSV help after its launch, and Ecobee tells me it’s one thing they’re exploring, however I wouldn’t wager on it. 

Putting in the Ecobee was just like most wired doorbells, though the chime field adaptor (heart) required some additional steps.

Set up and testing

As a wired doorbell, you don’t have to fret about charging the Ecobee, and because of always-on energy and radar movement detection, it picked up on all of the motion early, catching the usguy as he walked up my lengthy driveway. A whole lot of doorbells I check solely get individuals simply as they method the door, as a result of they depend on passive infrared (PIR) sensors, which have a shorter vary, and/or battery energy. If somebody is quick sufficient, I solely see the again of their head as they drop and run. The draw back with the Ecobee is that if the ability goes out, the doorbell is useless within the water, as there’s no backup battery. 

I put in the Ecobee at my entrance door utilizing my present doorbell wiring (right here’s a compatibility checker). Set up was simple, and it comes with the choice of a wedge mount to assist angle the digital camera 15 levels towards your door. As with most wired doorbells, I additionally needed to set up a chime converter in my mechanical chime field. Ecobee says this step is crucial for making certain the doorbell will get the proper energy. 

The app walked me by the whole lot clearly and prompted me to make use of the Ecobee thermostat and Ecobee SmartCamera as indoor chimes for the doorbell. I might additionally decide to make use of or disable my present chime. As I used to be testing the digital camera with the safety system, I obtained the choice to enroll in RapidSOS skilled monitoring ($10 a month) and to decide in to sharing video clips from the doorbell and the indoor digital camera with emergency companies. This video verification characteristic obtainable with some safety methods — together with SimpliSafe and Arlo — can assist expedite a response.

The doorbell reveals up within the Ecobee app, which — with the safety system and thermostats in — is now slightly cluttered. Tapping on the doorbell tile takes you to a stay view the place you may activate two-way speak, document a clip, take a snapshot, and sound a siren. To see recorded video, you faucet on View Historical past and see massive thumbnails of any motion-activated clips. There’s no technique to filter these by exercise or time, so it’s a must to scroll by to search out what you’re on the lookout for.

I additionally set the doorbell up with Apple House by scanning the HomeKit code on the doorbell mounting plate. Whereas there’s no technique to see recorded video in Apple House, you may view a livestream in your Apple TV and within the House app and, when the doorbell is pressed, obtain an interactive notification that allows you to see and speak to your customer. A neat characteristic of the combination is that if in case you have a sensible door lock — such because the Yale Guarantee 2 Lock I at present have put in — you may management the lock straight from the notification. 

Ecobee additionally works with Amazon Alexa to view livestreams and speak to and listen to guests by Echo Present sensible shows and the Alexa app. Sadly, the safety facet of Ecobee’s system doesn’t work in Apple House, but it surely does in Alexa. The sensors — each the safety sensors and the temp / occupancy sensors — work on each platforms to set off routines and automations. The safety system doesn’t work with Apple House however is appropriate with Alexa; you may arm and disarm with voice (utilizing a voice pin).

The place most doorbells use PIR movement detection, the Ecobee makes use of a mixture of radar movement detection, laptop imaginative and prescient, and on-device machine studying to detect exercise and ship acceptable alerts. It’s not the primary to do that; Ring has radar-powered detection on its Ring Professional 2 and Ring Battery Plus.

In testing, Ecobee’s sensing was far more correct than PIR alone at detecting related movement — I didn’t get a single alert for a tree department blowing within the wind or a automotive driving by. The mix of radar and laptop imaginative and prescient appears to be key right here. Ecobee calls it sensor fusion. “Pc imaginative and prescient can detect an individual far-off, however it will probably’t essentially decide how far-off they’re,” explains Greg Fyke, chief product officer of Ecobee. Combining radar with laptop imaginative and prescient gives extra context, together with how far-off the movement is. 


Wealthy notifications alow you to work together with the doorbell out of your lock display. Tapping on Discuss opens the Ecobee app.

Alone, radar and laptop imaginative and prescient will nonetheless detect any movement, however the Ecobee takes each inputs and makes use of native processing to filter and decide solely when an individual or a bundle has been detected. It was very correct in testing. I by no means as soon as obtained a false notification; there was all the time an individual or bundle when the doorbell stated there was. 

Nonetheless, as famous earlier, the system prioritizes packages, which means it didn’t ship me an alert when an individual approached my door if a bundle was already there. It is a main subject in case you are involved about porch pirates, one of many foremost causes individuals purchase video doorbells. You will get round this by turning off bundle alerts, you then get the individual notification (bundle alerts are additionally a paid characteristic), however that is one thing they should repair rapidly.

The opposite oddity is that after I walked out of the entrance door with out totally leaving my home, say to select up a bundle on the porch and return in, it didn’t detect me or document me. This might trigger lots of confusion if, say, one family member was monitoring a bundle on the doorstep remotely and didn’t understand somebody in the home had already retrieved it — as a result of the doorbell didn’t seize that occasion.


This picture reveals a FedEx supply individual gathering a bundle from my font door. The doorbell solely alerted me to a bundle being current, not an individual. So I missed him taking the bundle away.

On this vein, the doorbell doesn’t ship alerts for simply movement (and you may’t flip them on but; Ecobee says this characteristic might be enabled shortly after launch). It will probably document all movement occasions and allow you to view them within the video historical past. In my testing, this was hit and miss, and I didn’t get movement recording from occasions that set off different doorbell cameras, reminiscent of a automotive driving previous, even with the adjustable movement vary prolonged to the utmost 30 toes. 

This alert tailoring is all an effort to make the doorbell much less annoying, and I did obtain far fewer alerts from it than from the Ring Battery Plus I additionally had put in at my door. Nonetheless, I like getting alerts for movement. My cat, Smokey, who has change into accustomed to sitting on the entrance door and having it magically open (as a result of I get a movement alert on my cellphone and are available and let him in), began to get fairly aggravated with the brand new setup. He additionally wasn’t massive sufficient to set off the movement detection on the digital camera, because it by no means even recorded him sitting there.

Whereas the know-how is spectacular, Ecobee has lots of tweaking to do right here to fine-tune the expertise.

The doorbell’s 1080p HD video high quality is okay, however I might have preferred to see a bump up in picture high quality. Nearly each price-comparable possibility as we speak makes use of greater pixels. The 5MP sensor helps with coloration rendering, and HDR imaging meant I might see faces clearly, even when backlit. However as quickly as I zoomed in, issues began to pixelate. The usual IR night time imaginative and prescient can also be good. 

A wonderful discipline of view considerably makes up for this, nevertheless. With 187 levels on the diagonal and 175 on the vertical, the three:4 portrait side ratio reveals the whole lot clearly from high to backside and many backward and forward. There’s no bizarre fish-eye distortion as I’ve seen on lots of doorbells that promise head-to-toe view, and it even confirmed packages that have been pushed proper up towards the door, one thing the Ring Battery Plus utterly missed.

A neat zoom and observe characteristic on the digital camera zooms in on an individual as they method and tracks them to offer you a greater view of their face sooner. Nonetheless, due to the 1080p video, the face isn’t that clear from a distance, and as soon as they stand up shut, the digital camera typically will get confused and focuses on their chest, defeating your complete objective. This characteristic is in beta, so it’s going to hopefully get higher.

The shortage of native storage, 24/7 recording, or HomeKit Safe Video is disappointing. Nonetheless, Ecobee’s arguments for these selections — that they’d improve the value considerably — make sense; $160 is an effective worth for a doorbell this superior. However the argument is that their superior movement detection means you don’t want 24/7 recording as a result of it’s going to all the time provide you with a warning once you want it doesn’t maintain as a lot water, contemplating it didn’t catch me retrieving packages from inside my home.

The opposite annoyance is Ecobee’s app. It’s simply not designed as a safety digital camera / safety system app; it’s for controlling a sensible thermostat. As such, it’s a bit clunky and gradual to navigate, with lots of scrolling to see recorded footage. It took upwards of about 10 seconds to indicate a stay feed as nicely, though it was on 2.4 GHz in my home, and that probably could be quicker when you might get it onto 5GHz, which it does help. 

The app does some issues nicely. The stay view display is massive and well-laid out, and there are many settings to tinker with. I like the choice to show off the digital camera and microphone utterly, though I used to be disillusioned you may’t set it to show off robotically utilizing Ecobee’s Autopilot system. It is a characteristic the safety system and indoor digital camera use to arm and disarm once you or anybody in your family with the Ecobee app put in on their cellphone leaves or arrives each by geofencing and utilizing its connection to your Wi-Fi community as alerts. 

The Ecobee doorbell alongside the Nest doorbell (wired).

Must you purchase the Ecobee Sensible Doorbell Digital camera?

The Ecobee Sensible Doorbell Digital camera is a well-designed, modern doorbell with distinctive options that make it stand out from the crowded market. Its radar / laptop imaginative and prescient movement detection is correct, and its discipline of view is all-encompassing with out distortion. However in terms of software program, it wants some work. The Nest Doorbell (wired), which presents some free clips, has extra and smarter alerts, the choice for twenty-four/7 recording, and higher video high quality, remains to be my high choose for a video doorbell.

Nonetheless, when you personal an Ecobee Sensible Thermostat in a helpful location in your house, Ecobee’s doorbell digital camera is an effective possibility. Glancing at it on the best way to the door and having a heads-up as to what you’re about to see could be very cool. This integration can also be coming to the cheaper Ecobee with Voice Management and Ecobee Commonplace thermostats later this 12 months. 

If you happen to don’t have an Ecobee Thermostat, it’s nonetheless a great doorbell. Particularly, its tailor-made notifications, which translate into fewer alerts, will attraction to individuals who don’t really feel the necessity to find out about each squirrel that passes their entrance door. However as famous, it’s not for individuals who have porch pirate issues.

For these totally invested in a sensible house system that don’t have some other Ecobee merchandise, this most likely isn’t for you. At $160, it’s competitively priced, but it surely’s not a discount. It’s cheaper than the Ring Professional 2, however the Ring has higher video high quality and higher integration with Amazon Alexa. It’s costlier than the equally specced Arlo Important Wired doorbell ($129.99), which additionally works with Apple House however not HomeKit Safe Video, however that has extra sensible alert choices (together with for animals and automobiles). As talked about, in case you are a Google House family, the Nest Doorbell (wired) is great, and at launch, the Ecobee doesn’t work with Google House.

The Ecobee app works on the Apple Watch and you may management the doorbell by Apple House.

If you happen to’re on the lookout for a wired doorbell digital camera that works with Apple House, it’s one of many least costly choices. It seems nicer and has a greater construct high quality than the Aqara video doorbell, which has an identical worth and HomeKit Safe Video help. The Ecobee doesn’t help HKSV, so that you’ll be paying a month-to-month price for recorded video. Different higher-end doorbells that help HKSV are $200 or extra, however that month-to-month price does add up.

As a easy, cheap house safety system, Ecobee’s doorbell is compelling when paired with the Sensible Sensors. If you happen to’ve simply moved right into a small residence and wish some peace of thoughts, that is an easy-to-install system that can solely price you $10 a month for recorded video, 24/7 monitoring, and video verification. Nonetheless, the shortage of a backup battery or mobile connectivity does let it down (however can also be what makes it so inexpensive),

Moreover, as with all its merchandise, Ecobee has over-engineered this system, so like its thermostat, it might get higher with age. “The doorbell, in addition to our thermostats and our complete class of merchandise, are actually engineered to be designed for future wants,” says Fyke. Whilst you ought to by no means purchase a product based mostly on the promise of future upgrades, Ecobee’s historical past is an effective indicator right here. The Ecobee 3 you may need purchased seven years in the past now does significantly extra as we speak.

Photographs by Jennifer Pattison Tuohy / The Verge


Source link

Related posts

The Future of CMS 4 Trends You Need to Work Now


Tecno Megabook T1 laptop launched; price, specs, and features, check them all out


VanMoof S4 e-bike review: the one to buy


Leave a Comment